x

FOX 61 | Connecticut breaking news, weather, traffic, sports and social media

VERIFY: There is no link between past wireless technology upgrades and disease outbreaks

The VERIFY team has examined a claim that 5G upgrades are related to the coronavirus pandemic.

It’s no secret that people have been linking the spread of COVID-19 with 5G. Despite the lack of evidence to support them, the claims became amplified by celebrities.

Some people have tried to point to the release of previous wireless technology and the spread of respiratory diseases in an effort to further support those claims.

RELATED: VERIFY: No evidence to support Woody Harrelson's claim that 5G and COVID-19 are linked

Credit: VERIFY

For example, the meme above gets a number of things wrong and relies on heavily cherry-picked data to make a false argument.

THE QUESTION

Are there major respiratory disease outbreaks every time there is an upgrade to the world’s "electromagnetic field?"

THE ANSWER

No.

The image gives definitive years for when new generations or “Gs” were adopted. The reality is that the years are vague and these technologies often overlapped as they were rolled out.

Even if upgrades to these wireless waves helped spread respiratory diseases, you would see the outcome every year as opposed to just when they’re upgraded.

WHAT WE FOUND

So let’s break this down step by step. First, that the introduction of radio waves caused the Spanish flu of 1918.

There isn’t one date when radio waves were introduced, their usage and spread increased over time and onto new platforms. The Federal Communications Commission or FCC says the first public demonstration of radio was in the 1890s and the first program to transmit speech and music was in the 1900s. Federal regulation of American airwaves began in 1912, which suggests the public used radios and was exposed to radio waves by that time.

So the years don’t quite add up for the first claim.

The exact introduction of the various cellular technologies is about as murky as it is for radio waves. Each generation was released at different times in different countries.

An IT company from Belgium chronicled the history of wireless technology upgrades. They say, yes, 1G was first introduced in Tokyo in 1979. However, it didn’t cover all of Japan until 1984 and the first 1G operations in the U.S. weren’t approved until 1983.

So the year does match up if we’re talking about an American epidemic spread in 1979. Even so, while the 1979 seasonal flu had been called a “major epidemic” by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention at times, the virus, even back then, was believed by the National Institutes of Health to affect young people more because older generations built up immunity through a similar flu outbreak decades before. It’s hard to imagine that would be the case if the infection was being spread by an outside factor.

So, the claim linking a 1979 influenza outbreak to 1G doesn’t hold up.

The next part of the claim links a 1991 cholera epidemic to 2G.

First of all, cholera isn’t even a respiratory illness, contrary to the meme’s implication saying “it messes people breathing up.” The CDC describes cholera as an “acute, diarrheal illness,” and none of the CDC’s listed symptoms include respiratory problems.

There was a cholera epidemic in 1991 -- but it wasn’t worldwide or even in the United States. This epidemic happened in Latin America, specifically in Peru according to the CDC and NIH. At the time that the epidemic happened, 2G was being launched in Finland, according to the IT company’s timeline.

3G was launched well after the year listed in the meme -- it actually first activated in 2001. The CDC lists both 1998 and 2001 as years with moderate seasonal flu outbreaks. It’s also worth noting that when it launched, 3G was the strongest and fastest generation of wireless technology to date. Yet, the sicknesses the claim links to the rollout of 3G were comparatively weaker than those linked to radio waves or 2G.

4G launched in Scandinavia in 2009, and in late 2010 in the U.S. The last pandemic before COVID-19 was, in fact, the 2009 H1N1 outbreak.

Finally, while 5G has been launching in many places recently while COVID-19 is spreading worldwide, even that link can be debated. South Korea launched 5G infrastructure as early as 2018, and 5G began to rollout in the United States as early as March 2019. As VERIFIED previously, COVID-19 has spread in places that have yet to install 5G infrastructure and the spread has been contained in South Korea, which has heavier 5G infrastructure than most other countries.

BOTTOM LINE

There isn’t a trend of major respiratory disease outbreaks occurring the same year as upgrades in wireless technology. Radio waves were introduced well before the Spanish flu pandemic, seasonal flu outbreaks happened the same as any other year in 1979 and 1998, cholera isn’t a respiratory illness, several of these years don’t actually coincide with the launch of the new technology worldwide and/or in the U.S. and the link between the current pandemic and 5G is weak at best.

If there was a link between respiratory illnesses and wireless technology, it would always have an impact -- not just when the wireless technology was launched and not just during flu season.

Influenza outbreaks have been taking place since well before the launch of wireless technology. One research paper says the first influenza pandemic happened as early as 1580.

Something you’d like VERIFIED? Click here to submit your story.